FBR Introduces Faceless Appeals Rules for Sales Tax and Federal Excise Tax Cases in Pakistan

The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has introduced a new framework for handling sales tax and federal excise appeals through a faceless appellate system, marking a further step towards digitising tax administration in Pakistan. Under S.R.O. 2134(I)/2026, issued on November 18, 2026, the FBR has inserted Chapter XIV-CA, covering Rules 150ZZGB to 150ZZGN, into the Sales Tax Rules, 2006. The new provisions establish procedures for processing appeals before the Commissioner (Appeals) under Section 45B of the Sales Tax Act and Section 33 of the Federal Excise Act. The framework is designed to shift appellate proceedings towards electronic processing, reduce direct interaction between taxpayers and tax officials, and introduce greater procedural standardisation in the handling of tax disputes.

According to the notification, the new system will become operational from a date separately notified by the FBR. Once implemented, taxpayers will be required to submit their appeals through the Iris electronic portal, where cases will be distributed among appellate authorities through an automated algorithm. The allocation process will be random, while the identity of the Commissioner (Appeals) handling a particular case will remain anonymous throughout the proceedings, including in the final order. This arrangement separates the identity of the appellate authority from the taxpayer and other parties involved in the dispute. The electronic allocation mechanism is intended to establish a standardised process for assigning cases and limit direct contact between appellants and the officials responsible for deciding their appeals.

The notification also outlines procedures for conducting hearings through electronic means. Appellate proceedings may take place through video hearings, during which the face of the Commissioner (Appeals) will remain concealed and the voice will be electronically modulated to protect the officer’s identity. The system will also allow cases to be decided on the basis of written submissions where the appellate authority considers an oral hearing unnecessary or where proceedings can be concluded through the available documentation. Respondents will be required to submit para-wise comments within seven days, providing their position on the grounds raised in the appeal. These requirements establish defined timelines for submissions and introduce a digital process for communication between appellants, respondents and the appellate authority.

Specific timelines have also been prescribed for applications seeking a stay on disputed tax proceedings or recovery. Under the new framework, stay applications must be heard within two working days, while decisions are required within seven working days. These timelines are intended to provide a more structured mechanism for addressing urgent matters arising during the appeal process. The notification further establishes requirements for issuing appellate decisions electronically. Orders will carry a Document Identification Number (DIN) but will not disclose the name or signature of the Commissioner (Appeals). Their placement in the taxpayer’s electronic folder will constitute valid service, allowing official communication to take place through the portal without requiring conventional physical delivery. The rules also prevent cases from being remanded for de novo consideration, meaning the appellate process will not send matters back for a fresh examination under the same procedure.

The FBR has additionally addressed situations in which technical problems could affect the submission of appeals. If downtime of the Iris portal is confirmed by the Board, the interruption will be treated as sufficient cause for delay, providing protection to taxpayers who are unable to meet filing requirements because of officially recognised system disruptions. At the same time, the notification clarifies that the introduction of the faceless appeals mechanism does not remove the option of filing a direct appeal before the relevant Tribunal. Taxpayers will therefore retain this available legal route alongside the newly established appellate framework. Although the rules have now been formally introduced through S.R.O. 2134(I)/2026, their practical implementation remains dependent on a separate commencement notification from the FBR. Taxpayers, businesses and tax practitioners will need to monitor that announcement to determine when the new digital appeals process becomes operational.

Follow the PakBanker Whatsapp Channel for updates across Pakistan’s banking ecosystem.