Pakistan Debt Servicing Reform Could Save Rs2.5 Trillion and Provide Tax Relief

Pakistan’s growing debt-servicing expenditure has renewed questions about government borrowing practices, banking sector returns and the financial burden placed on taxpayers, as former federal finance secretary Mohammad Younus Dagha has proposed reforms that could generate annual savings of Rs2,100 billion to Rs2,500 billion. In his assessment of the country’s public debt management, Dagha argues that ordinary citizens and businesses should not be required to shoulder additional taxation to finance costs that could potentially be reduced through more efficient government borrowing. He highlights that debt servicing currently consumes an amount equivalent to 125 per cent of the Federal Board of Revenue taxes retained by the federal government, 68.5 per cent of its total revenues and nearly three times the country’s defence budget. These figures, according to the former finance secretary, raise serious concerns about whether public borrowing is being managed efficiently and whether taxpayers are receiving adequate protection against unnecessarily high financing costs. He argues that the government must examine the relationship between the interest it pays commercial banks on government securities and the relatively low cost at which banks obtain deposits from customers.

The banking sector’s deposit structure is central to Dagha’s argument, particularly because a substantial proportion of Pakistan’s bank deposits are maintained in current accounts that do not generate interest payments for account holders. In a country where many citizens prefer interest-free banking arrangements, current accounts represent nearly 40 per cent of total bank deposits, providing commercial banks with an inexpensive source of funding. According to State Bank of Pakistan data cited by Dagha, banks paid an average interest rate of only 5.53 per cent on their total deposits in September 2026, including current accounts on which no interest is paid. Meanwhile, the government borrowed through 12-month treasury bills in October 2026 at an interest rate of 12.79 per cent, creating a gross difference of 7.26 percentage points between banks’ average deposit costs and government borrowing rates. Dagha argues that a more prudent borrowing arrangement would maintain this difference within approximately one to two percentage points. Instead, the existing gap allows commercial banks to obtain low-cost deposits and invest substantial portions of their funds in government securities offering considerably higher returns. He maintains that taxpayers ultimately finance these returns through government debt-servicing expenditure, while consumers and businesses continue facing high petroleum levies, energy-related taxes and income tax rates.

The scale of banking deposits and commercial banks’ exposure to government securities further illustrates the financial relationship between the government and the banking industry. By June 2026, current accounts held approximately Rs15.3 trillion, representing nearly 40 per cent of total deposits compared with 37 per cent a year earlier. The State Bank also reported that the Rs3.67 trillion increase in deposits during the first half of 2026 was primarily driven by current accounts. Meanwhile, total bank deposits increased from Rs13.35 trillion in December 2018 to nearly Rs41 trillion in September 2026, representing more than three times their earlier level. Dagha questions whether this growing pool of financial savings is supporting productive investment, industrial expansion, business development and employment generation or increasingly flowing into government securities that offer banks substantial returns. According to State Bank figures, commercial banks held Rs40.36 trillion in government securities in September 2026. Applying the 7.26 percentage-point difference between the average deposit cost and the government’s borrowing rate to these holdings produces an estimated annualised gross interest-rate differential of approximately Rs2.93 trillion. Dagha estimates that limiting government borrowing rates to one or two percentage points above banks’ average deposit costs could generate annual gross savings of Rs2,100 billion to Rs2,500 billion, depending on debt maturities and repricing arrangements. He also acknowledges that such a reduction could lower the State Bank’s annual interest earnings by approximately Rs118 billion, although he considers this a relatively small amount compared with the potential savings for the wider economy.

To address the issue, Dagha proposes introducing legislation that would limit the interest paid to commercial banks on government securities to a reasonable margin of one to two percentage points above the average rate banks pay depositors. He stresses that implementation would require careful coordination to prevent disruptions to monetary policy, government borrowing operations and overall financial stability. The proposed framework would also introduce greater transparency into public debt management by requiring the Ministry of Finance and the State Bank of Pakistan to publish quarterly reports detailing government borrowing from banks and other investors, the interest payments associated with that borrowing and the average cost of funds for commercial banks. These reports should additionally disclose the actual savings generated through lower government borrowing costs, allowing taxpayers and policymakers to assess whether the proposed reforms are producing measurable fiscal benefits. Dagha argues that the resulting financial space should be directed towards reducing the tax burden rather than financing additional government expenditure. Among his recommendations is a reduction in the Petroleum Development Levy and General Sales Tax imposed on electricity bills, which could lower fuel, transportation and production costs while easing inflationary pressures. He also proposes doubling the annual income tax exemption threshold from Rs600,000 to Rs1.2 million to provide greater financial relief to salaried individuals and low-income taxpayers.

Further recommendations focus on improving the tax structure for exporters, businesses and corporate investors. Dagha proposes restoring the Final Tax Regime for exporters, under which tax deducted from export proceeds would represent their final income tax liability, even if the applicable rate remains at 2 per cent. He argues that this arrangement would simplify tax compliance, reduce uncertainty and improve the competitiveness of Pakistani exporters by bringing their tax treatment closer to that of businesses operating in comparable economies. He also calls for the complete abolition of the super tax, which reportedly generates between Rs400 billion and Rs500 billion annually but has become a significant deterrent to investment. According to his proposal, the highest effective income tax rate on corporate, business and other incomes should be capped at 35 per cent. Lowering the effective tax burden could improve Pakistan’s attractiveness as an investment destination while allowing businesses and individuals to retain more income for savings, consumption, expansion and employment generation. Dagha believes that the proposed debt-servicing savings could finance these tax reforms without requiring additional borrowing, provided the government ensures that the resulting fiscal space is used for taxpayer relief instead of increased public spending. He argues that reducing excessive taxation is essential for reviving economic activity, encouraging private investment, supporting businesses and addressing poverty. The broader objective of the proposed reforms is to redirect resources currently consumed by high debt-servicing costs towards households and productive sectors, creating conditions for stronger economic growth and improved business competitiveness.

Follow the PakBanker Whatsapp Channel for updates across Pakistan’s banking ecosystem.