WB Rates Punjab Green Development Project as ‘Moderately Satisfactory’, Revises Closure to 2025

The World Bank has assessed the progress of the Punjab Green Development Programme, a $200 million initiative aimed at strengthening environmental governance and fostering green investments in Pakistan’s largest province, as “moderately satisfactory.” The update was shared through the World Bank’s latest Implementation Status and Results Report (ISR), which also rated the overall achievement toward the project’s development objectives at the same level.

The Punjab Green Development Programme was launched in May 2018, with the core goal of reinforcing environmental institutions and driving sustainable economic growth through targeted green investments. The programme originally had a closing date of June 30, 2023. However, official documents indicate that it has now undergone three separate restructurings, pushing the revised project completion date to November 30, 2025.

According to details shared in the ISR, the total project cost was initially set at $200 million. This amount has since been adjusted to $182.89 million following revisions aligned with the programme’s evolving scope and implementation dynamics. As of the latest update, approximately $134.69 million has been disbursed, representing around 71.6 percent of the revised project funding.

Despite this level of financial disbursement, the World Bank noted that several of the programme’s ambitious targets under the “Promoting Green Investments” component remain unmet. However, it added that these targets have now been revised to more realistic levels, with expectations that they can be achieved before the new project closure date in late 2025.

The ISR underlined that while notable progress has been made in certain areas, challenges continue to affect the full realization of the intended outcomes. The moderately satisfactory rating reflects a mixed picture: successful institutional groundwork on one hand and delayed investments in specific green initiatives on the other.

Analysts observe that the Punjab Green Development Programme remains a critical part of Pakistan’s broader climate and environmental agenda. With global funding bodies like the World Bank keen on supporting projects tied to climate resilience and low-carbon transitions, the success of such programmes could also pave the way for future international cooperation.

In Islamabad, policymakers continue to view the project as essential for bolstering provincial environmental governance, improving regulatory compliance, and introducing cleaner production practices across key industrial zones. These shifts are increasingly necessary as Punjab grapples with urban pollution, industrial waste management challenges, and the rising impacts of climate variability.

Moving forward, the focus will be on ensuring that the revised targets are met within the extended timeframe. The World Bank’s ongoing supervision will likely emphasize both the technical quality of interventions and the measurable on-ground impacts to validate the programme’s contribution to sustainable development goals.

With roughly two years left before the new closure date, the success of the Punjab Green Development Programme will hinge on translating the groundwork laid so far into tangible results that advance Pakistan’s green transition efforts and build a more resilient environmental framework for the province.