The International Monetary Fund has raised a significant red flag regarding the Government of Pakistan’s plan to privatize Zarai Taraqiati Bank Limited, suggesting the move could severely restrict credit access for the nation’s vulnerable small-scale farmers. In its latest Governance and Corruption Diagnostic report, the IMF highlighted that ZTBL remains the only specialized financial institution dedicated to the agricultural sector, and its transition to private ownership could jeopardize the development financing that 97 percent of Pakistan’s farming community relies upon. This observation validates the long-standing concerns held by several cabinet members and parliamentarians who argue that conventional banks are historically reluctant to lend to low-income agricultural groups.
The IMF’s scrutiny comes at a time when ZTBL has demonstrated a remarkable operational turnaround. Following years of being plagued by poor governance and a high volume of non-performing loans, a new management team appointed in recent years has made aggressive strides in cleaning up the bank’s balance sheet. According to unapproved financial statements for the period ending December 2025, the bank has successfully reduced its bad loans by approximately 25 percent over the last three years, bringing the total down to Rs 50 billion. This recovery was achieved by dismantling corruption networks and leveraging the revised Loans for Agriculture, Commercial and Industrial Purposes Act to recover nearly Rs 9.8 billion.
Despite these internal improvements, the push for privatization continues to move through the regulatory pipeline. The Privatization Commission board recently recommended a transaction structure to the Cabinet Committee on Privatization, though sources indicate that the board itself remains divided over the final framework. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has reportedly held extensive consultations with his kitchen cabinet on the matter. The core of the debate lies in the behavior of the private banking sector; conventional lenders in Pakistan have shown little interest in government-backed social schemes, such as the electric bike initiative or low-cost housing, often citing risk concerns or demanding sweeping foreclosure authorities.
The potential impact on the grassroots level is staggering given the data from the 7th Agricultural Census 2024. The census reveals that 97 percent of Pakistani farmers own less than 12.5 acres of land, with 61 percent holding less than 2.5 acres. These smallholders live “crop to crop,” lacking the savings necessary to fund their own working capital. Without a specialized state-run bank like ZTBL, these farmers are often forced to turn to middlemen who charge exorbitant interest rates, further trapping them in a cycle of debt. The IMF footnote explicitly warns that “privatization could raise issues of access to credit for smallholders, particularly their development financing,” a sentiment echoed by those who view the bank as a vital social safety net rather than just a commercial entity.
Financially, ZTBL’s recent performance makes a strong case for its retention under state control. The bank’s cumulative gross profit over the last three years soared to Rs 70 billion, a 280 percent increase compared to the combined profits of the previous two decades. This profitability translated into a Rs 27 billion tax contribution to the national exchequer. Furthermore, the bank’s equity rose from Rs 60 billion in 2022 to roughly Rs 95 billion by September 2025. During this period, the bank disbursed Rs 250 billion in credit, including Rs 42 billion specifically under the Prime Minister’s Kissan Package, reaching segments of the population that are traditionally ignored by the mainstream financial system.
As the government weighs the short-term fiscal gains of a sale against the long-term food security and economic stability of the rural population, the IMF’s warning adds a layer of global institutional pressure. The debate now shifts to whether a middle ground can be found—perhaps a partial privatization or a structural reform that preserves the bank’s developmental mandate. For the millions of farmers holding tiny plots of land across Pakistan, the fate of ZTBL is not just a matter of high finance, but a critical factor in their continued ability to sustain their livelihoods and contribute to the national harvest.
Follow the PakBanker Whatsapp Channel for updates across Pakistan’s banking ecosystem.