Pakistan’s formal retail and fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) sector continues to struggle against an uneven competitive environment, as widespread tax evasion among undocumented retailers weakens compliance efforts and shifts additional financial burdens onto registered businesses. Industry observers argue that the country’s existing tax structure, combined with weak enforcement, has created significant distortions in the retail value chain, allowing informal operators to gain a pricing advantage while compliant manufacturers absorb increasing costs.
At the centre of the issue lies Pakistan’s General Sales Tax (GST) framework, where the standard sales tax rate of 18 per cent is already considered high by many businesses. Beyond this, products subject to standard sales tax also face an additional four per cent levy when sold through unregistered retailers, alongside a further income tax burden that effectively raises costs for formal businesses and, ultimately, consumers. With a retail ecosystem dominated by undocumented operators, these extra taxes are increasingly viewed as punitive measures that penalise compliance rather than improve tax collection.
Pakistan’s retail market remains overwhelmingly informal, with estimates suggesting that more than 90 per cent of retailers operate outside documented tax systems. Despite repeated efforts by authorities to broaden the tax base, small retailers have shown limited willingness to formally register. Several tax expansion initiatives introduced over the past three decades have struggled to deliver meaningful results, including more recent trader documentation efforts. Even among registered players across retail and wholesale channels, concerns persist over weak tax reporting and minimal compliance levels.
For formal FMCG businesses, the consequences are becoming increasingly difficult to ignore. Companies operating within documented supply chains are often unable to fully distance themselves from small, undocumented wholesalers and retailers, as doing so risks sacrificing market access and shelf presence, particularly in smaller cities and rural markets. Yet remaining connected to these networks creates additional financial pressure, as businesses must either absorb the cost of higher taxation or attempt to pass it onto consumers in a highly price-sensitive environment.
This imbalance has contributed to a widening price gap between documented and undocumented businesses. Industry participants argue that informal manufacturers or importers, who avoid tax obligations, can often offer products at substantially lower prices, enabling them to rapidly gain market share. In sectors driven heavily by affordability and consumer spending pressures, even small pricing differences can significantly influence purchasing decisions, leaving formal businesses at a disadvantage despite maintaining regulatory compliance.
The broader challenge also highlights structural weaknesses in Pakistan’s GST collection mechanism, particularly where enforcement remains limited. Tax collection under the value-added model requires compliance across every stage of the supply chain, including manufacturers, distributors, wholesalers and retailers. However, when one or more segments operate outside official systems, tax leakages emerge and compliant businesses are forced to shoulder the burden.
Industry experts argue that previous enforcement approaches, including punitive taxes targeting undocumented businesses, have failed to produce the intended outcomes. Policies aimed at distinguishing between tax filers and non-filers have had limited success in expanding the formal tax net, while additional taxes imposed on unregistered retailers have similarly struggled to encourage documentation.
In response, some analysts are advocating for an expanded use of the Third Schedule under Pakistan’s Sales Tax Act as a more practical solution to retail tax evasion. Under this framework, manufacturers collect sales tax upfront on behalf of the entire retail chain, while fixed retail prices are printed directly on product packaging. This mechanism currently applies to a range of consumer goods, including beverages, biscuits, chocolates, tea, soaps, shampoos and packaged food items, helping reduce opportunities for underreporting and undocumented discounts.
However, several high-consumption categories, including cooking oil, milk and dairy products, ketchup, infant formula and frozen foods, continue to remain under the standard sales tax regime, where taxation occurs across multiple stages of the supply chain. Industry stakeholders believe this layered approach increases operational complexity, creates room for tax leakages and limits transparency, particularly in smaller towns and underserved markets where undocumented retail activity is widespread.
Expanding the Third Schedule to additional FMCG categories is increasingly being discussed as a potential pathway to improve tax collection efficiency and strengthen market transparency. Advocates argue that requiring printed retail prices would not only reduce opportunities for overcharging but also provide consumers with greater pricing visibility while creating fairer competition for formal businesses. At the same time, upfront GST collection could help authorities improve revenue collection from a retail market that remains largely undocumented.
While such reforms may help reduce immediate leakages, industry participants stress that sustainable progress will still depend on broader efforts to formally document Pakistan’s retail sector. Without stronger enforcement and more effective incentives for registration, the country’s formal businesses are likely to remain caught between rising compliance costs and growing competition from untaxed market players.
Follow the PakBanker Whatsapp Channel for updates across Pakistan’s banking ecosystem.